The last part of the puzzle is by far the most complicated: la plantilla, or the template, a formation of players built around a philosophy of play, a structure that is balanced honoring the successes of the past under a body of principles that represents the club. It’s more than just buying players to suit financial or sporting needs but finding the right balance of players, building a system that outlasts the contributions of one coach or one set of players. Real Madrid had it with the DiStefano/Puskas teams. Butragueno’s quinta had that. It looks like a return to the mismatched team-building of the Galactico era is set, but is that the right call for this squad at this time? Heresy to say, but should they look at the Barcelona model?
Iker Casillas is clearly paying attention to his Catalan team-mates on the national team. “I’d like the club (Madrid) to be more Spanish”, he said. Some people took it to be a thinly veiled xenophobia, that the club had become too dominated by Dutch players under Mijatovich, but Iker wasn’t talking just about the foreigners at the club, he was talking about the template: their style of play as well. People confuse the play of Barca, that tiqui-taqui, small ball, possession game and label it the Catalan-way, or the Ajax way, or the Barca way, but this is also primarily the way that Spain play and have always played. It is as much their footballing identity as that route-1, hoof it up the park nonsense is England’s.
Spain are European champions. Its players have taken la furia roja, never valued all that much in a fractured society, whistled at in Bilbao and Barcelona, ignored in much of the rest of the country, and made them national heroes. The madridistas though wonder why there are so few merengues on the squad? They see its captain Iker Casillas and fullback Sergio Ramos representing the club, but the blaugrana have Xavi, Iniesta, Puyol and a slew of young players like Busquets and Pique getting call-ups. They see faces like Diego Lopez of Villareal, Alvaro Arbeloa of Liverpool, and now Juan Mata of Valencia, all ex-Castilla players donning the red, gold and blue kit of Spain. They realize too that, if Real Madrid are yin to Barca’s yang in Spain’s footballing club culture, then the club need to recapture that template for themselves or else be usurped by their rivals in the national footballing debate.
When Florentino Perez fired Vicente del Bosque after the 2003 Champions League final and hired Carlos Queroz right from under Sir Alex Ferguson’s nose, no one could possibly have imagined that the club would endure 2 failed presidencies, numerous club presidents and sporting directors, 2 Primera titles and no European trophies. More importantly they have gone through 8 first team coaches: Carlos Queroz, Jose Antonio Camacho, Mariano Garcia Remon, Wanderlei Luxemburgo, Fabio Capello, Bernd Schuster, and now Juande Ramos. With them came an infinite series of tactical formations and systems; defensive 4-5-1’s, attacking 4-3-3’s, direct 4-4-2’s, even combinations of the sort: 4-3-1-2, 4-2-3-1, and even Luxemburgo’s “magic quadrilateral” or 4-2-2-2. It didn’t work, but it was sure cool. In the same time, Barca have had 1 president, two coaches and one system: a Dutch 4-3-3 that has its roots in the 1970’s when Rinus Michels and Johann Cruyff brought it to the Camp Nou.
It’s no wonder Barca play with such flair, they have players who come prebuilt for their style of play. New signings like a Samuel Eto’o, a Thierry Henry, or a Seydou Keita can be plugged in to suit their need. Madrid on the other hand have been built like a patchwork quilt, a hodge podge of players who don’t fit together, culled from the failed transfer policies of the last 4 management teams. Whomever takes control has to address this ineffectiveness of design and use the Spanish National Team as the template. Remove players who don’t fit and bring in those that do. Here’s what I would do.
Goalkeeping
No doubts there. Iker Casillas is captain of Spain. He should be captain at Real Madrid. The backup ought to be Jordi Codina for cup games. Dudek is a liability. Cheap, but a liability.
Defense
Use a flat back four and play high up the pitch. Get rid of Salgado and Heinze. Let Metzelder go back to Germany and sanction the removal of Cannavaro back to Juve. While Sergio Ramos is first choice right-back for Spain, and a talent like no other, he is not a world class right-back. He gets caught out of position, he doesn’t have the pace to be a winger, but his instincts are to attack. If there were a role like the one Franz Beckenbauer played for Germany this would be the guy to play it. Put him with a disciplined centerback next to him and he thrives. Short of that they have Pepe. This is where they need help: Maicon from Inter would help. He attacks well, but he tracks back, too. Left back is also a problem: Philip Lahm is a disciplined and talented German international and a perfect signing.
Midfield
This is where Madrid are strongest. Short of contracting Xavi, Iniesta and Toure they have the next best thing with Lassana Diarra, Wesley Snejder, and Rafael Van der Vaart. The last two Dutchmen played the Xavi and Iniesta roles for Ajax as youngsters so they would be willing, but neither Schuster nor Ramos had the faith in the defense to play such an attacking formation. With the back shored-up they can take advantage of their main strength: creative midfielders who play possession football up front and an attacking doberman ball-winner at the back. Fernando Gago can back them up, as can Dani Parejo. Loan out Javi Garcia and let Ruben de la Red retire with his heart condition. Signings: Cesc Fabregas would be perfect in this role but he is still a few years away from leaving the captain’s badge at Arsenal. Kaka is too expensive, so why not get his understudy Yoann Gourcuff who played at Bordeaux this year and stood out in that role. Rotate Snejder, Van der Vaart and Gourcuff along the way in fact keeping them all fresh.
Forward
This is where the balance of Madrid is tested. Keep Huntelaar in the striker’s role. He has enough pace to play away from goal and enough strength to play with his back to goal. Higuain gives you the intangibles on the right or just behind Klaas-Jan. If you must sell Huntelaar and think he isn’t material for the Spanish Primera, then get Villa or Benzema here, although I think both are also too expensive. You can’t give Raul the Fernando Hierro treatment yet, but take minutes off, make him a super-sub, but get him away from the spine of the team. Let Saviola leave, give Ruud van Nistelrooj a way out and boot Arjen Robben off the squad. Signings: This is where you buy and buy big. The three names I’m thinking of here are David Silva, Franck Ribery, or even Simao Sabrosa. Better yet, if Diego is going to Juve, would the bianconeri sell the atomic ant Sebastian Giovinco for this role?
That’s what I would do. What would you?